I am finally getting to watch this movie, and am loving the Valkyries music at the beginning. Last night I finished my senior thesis; it is the hardest paper I've ever written...to have that much breadth and freedom is almost paralyzing. I felt like Richard Blayze on the finale of Top Chef: 1,2,3 and CHOKE.
But, I finally got a tight thesis statement: Reactions to Aristotle's Theory of Fear and Pity in Bleak House and Great Expectations. I broke the statement down into three reactions: Resolve, Retreat and Ruin. Just shy of 11,000 words, it is a literary force to be reckoned with. GRE's here I come; with my hat in my hand!
Below is a CS Lewis essay on Myth Sightings in Perelandra:
Corrie Greene
C.S. Lewis
Dr. King
11 April 2011
Odysseus, Virgil, Charlemagne, Nietzsche, and Tennyson: How Myth Influenced Perelandra
C.S. Lewis’ Perelandra is a reimagining of one of the primary biblical myths, the Fall of Man. Or as David Downing describes in his essay, “Paradise Retained,” it is a story of the, “reality of myth and how ordinary mortals may be called upon to engage in mythic labours” (Downing, in Edwards, 35.) To underscore the theme of Perelandra, Lewis makes several references to both classical mythology and biblical myth. Among the classical are: Circe, Alcina, Hesperides, The Legends of Charlemagne, and the tale of the Lotus Eaters in Odysseus. These mythic references function to inform Ransom’s own journey and struggle to be a hero, in spite of his Piebald existence- having one leg in the heroic and the other in mortality.
In Chapter 4 Ransom comes face to face with the Green Lady for the first time. He is surprised to see a woman, and then surprised at himself for his reaction to her. She is, “strangely accompanied,” thronged by, “beasts and birds” (Lewis, 48.) He begins to doubt himself and confronts his fear of hallucination: “Was this the beginning of the hallucinations he had feared? Or another myth coming out into the world of fact-perhaps a more terrible myth…” (Lewis, 48.) It is at this point that Lewis, through the mind of Ransom, references Circe and Alcina.
Judith Yarnall in her book, Transformations of Circe, explains that it is impossible to know where Circe the enchantress, “first took on deed and shape,” however, she does appear in Homer’s Odyssey. Circe lives on an island of Homer’s creation called Aiaia, where she entertained sailors and eventually turned them into pigs. Yarnall also finds her in Virgil’s Aeneid as the, “ruler of a promontory where the air vibrates with the howls of chained and enraged beasts.” She also turns the wheel that governs incarnations, and is the fair witch in Spenser’s Renaissance, “bower of bliss waiting for virile young lovers…” She is also found in 17th century ballet and in James Joyce’s Ulysses (Yarnall, 1.)
The thesis of Yarnall’s book gives insight into why Circe springs to Ransom’s mind as he encounters the Green Lady covered by animals on an otherworldly island: “No matter what century or work Circe appears in, she is associated with our bodily vulnerability…” (Yarnall, 2.) Using this observation as an inspiration, the reader of Perlandra can see the pertinence of the Circe reference. Not only are the circumstances parallel to the setting of the Odyssey, but also Ransom himself is in a psychologically and physically vulnerable place. He is naked, on poor footing because of the fluid nature of the island, and he has just experienced the Green Lady’s flash of disappointment upon seeing him. He is unsure of the purpose of his visit to this world or why the eldila had sent him. His life is completely infused with vulnerabilities.
Ransom also references Alcina at his first meeting with the Green Lady. In Bulfinch’s Mythology Thomas Bulfinch provides the story of a brave knight returning home to aid the Emperor of France. He and other soldiers reach Alcina’s castle by the sea. Alcina is referred to as a, “powerful enchantress.” “Alcina had fixed her eyes on me and planned to get me into her power…no sooner…were we…moved off than I saw my folly but it was too late to repent…Soon Alcina, sated with her conquest grew indifferent, then weary of me, and at last to get rid of me, she changed me into this form, as she had done to many lovers before me, making some of them olives, some of them palms…” (Bulfinch, 64.) As the Green Lady appears to Ransom he is surrounded by some of the most interesting and intoxicating foliage and trees he has ever experienced, it stands to reason that fear could allow him to reference Alcina’s powers to turn warriors into her own personal arboretum.
Lewis also uses allusions to Hesperides, Titian’s painted satyrs, Artemis, Maenads, and satyrs dancing in Italian woods. Since the satyr is mentioned twice in Perelandra, it is worth noting that both Maenads and satyrs have a prominent place in the cult of Dionysis, who is the twice-born figure of Greek Mythology and the symbol of Nietzsche’s belief, explains Paul Valadier in his essay, “Dionysus versus the Crucified,” that Dionysus was the ideal image of, “the affirmation of life,” and that Christ or the “Crucified,” was the image of the negation or suppression of life (Valadier in Allison, 247.) One can hear the echoes of Nietzsche’s argument of the suppressive nature of Christianity in the relentless campaign the Un-Man levels at the Green Lady:
“Because this forbidding is such a strange one…” (89.)
“…Maleldil has sent you other men whom it had never entered your mind to think of…” (90.)
“They do not need to wait for him to tell them what is good, but know it for themselves as he does. They are, as it were, little Maleldils” (91.)
“He does not want you to go on to the new fruits you have not tasted before” (98.)
“Are you certain that He really wishes to be always obeyed?” (99)
“A real disobeying, a real branching out, this is what He secretly longs for…” (100.)
“Your deepest will, at present, is to obey Him-to be always as you are now, only His beast or His very young child” (102.)
Although Perelandra is riddled with mythic references and allusions one other from Greek Mythology stands out. As Ransom is chasing the Un Man, after their battle, he rides on the back of the large fish into the area of water inhabited by mermaids and mermen. Lewis writes:
“He (Ransom) noticed presently that some of the water people in his immediate neighbourhood seemed to be feeding. They were picking dark masses of something off the water with their webbed frog-like hands and devouring it…The sight of their eating had reminded him that he was hungry…(he eats the seaweed)…As soon as he had eaten a few mouthfuls of the seaweed he felt his mind oddly changed…He felt his memory of the Green Lady and all her promised descendants and all the issues which had occupied him ever since he came to Perelandra rapidly fading from his mind” (138,139.)
This sequence in Ransom’s journey on Perelandra is a patchwork of mythic references. The riding on large fish again references the story of Alcina: “I (the soldier) who was rash did not hesitate to follow her, but swam my horse over and mounted the back of the fish” (Bulfinch, 723.) The mermaids appear in myriad ancient references, including The Legends of Charlemagne, and the sirens of the Odyssey. Finally, the bliss and forgetfulness inducing seaweed is reminiscent of the Country of the Lotus-Eaters encountered by Odysseus’ men as they sail from Troy. Tennyson describes the feeling of eating the lotus in his poem, “The Lotus-eaters,”
To lend our hearts and spirits wholly
To the influence of mild melancholy
To muse and brood and live again in memory
…
Surely surely slumber is more sweet than toil, the shore
Than labour in the deep mid-ocean, wind and wave and oar
Oh rest ye, brother mariners, we will not wander more.
In God in the Dock Lewis writes, “In the enjoyment of a great myth we come nearest to experiencing as a concrete what can otherwise be understood only as an abstraction…To be truly Christian we must both assent to the historical fact and also receive the myth (fact though it has become) with the same imaginative embrace which we accord other myths. The one is hardly more necessary than the other” (Lewis, Dock, 66,67.) The narrator in Perelandra reveals Ransom’s thoughts to the reader in Chapter 11: “Ransom had been perceiving that the triple distinction of truth from myth and of both from fact was purely terrestrial” (122.) Ransom’s thoughts mirror Lewis’ explanation of the importance of myth to the Christian.
Through his use of biblical and classical mythology, Lewis creates an environment where Ransom is called upon to experience the myth-like qualities of the world of Perelandra, interpret them, and act upon them, just as we Christians must do here on earth.